Distinguish Earth's yearly orbit and its tilted axis from daily rotation, and use evidence to explain how the tilt causes seasons.
Besides spinning daily on its axis, Earth also travels in a huge yearly loop around the sun, called an orbit or revolution, taking about 365 days to complete. Importantly, Earth's axis is tilted, not straight up and down, and that tilt stays pointed in roughly the same direction all year as Earth orbits.
This tilt is what causes seasons, not distance from the sun. When your hemisphere is tilted toward the sun, sunlight hits more directly and days are longer, giving warmer weather, summer. When your hemisphere is tilted away, sunlight is more spread out and days are shorter, giving cooler weather, winter. The Northern and Southern Hemispheres experience opposite seasons at the same time because they tilt toward or away from the sun oppositely.
Mastery looks like: They can explain that Earth's tilt, not distance from the sun, causes seasons and support this using the opposite-hemisphere-seasons evidence.
Common stumbles: Believing Earth is closer to the sun in summer and farther in winter; confusing the yearly orbit with the daily rotation.