Test several materials against a specific job, like keeping something dry, and use the results to choose the best material.
Every material is good at some jobs and bad at others. A raincoat needs to keep water out, so it should be waterproof, not absorbent. A towel needs to soak up water fast, so it should be absorbent, not waterproof. Picking the right material means matching its properties to the job.
The best way to choose is to test, not guess. If you are not sure which material will work, drip water on a few of them, or press on a few of them, and compare the real results side by side.
Mastery looks like: They can test two or more materials against a specific job and choose the best one, explaining the property-based reason.
Common stumbles: Choosing a material based on appearance instead of a real test; forgetting to keep the test fair by using the same amount of water or force on each material.