Apply the volume and surface area formulas for prisms, cylinders, pyramids, and cones, distinguishing vertical height from slant height.
Prisms and cylinders share one volume pattern: Volume = (area of the base) * height -- stack copies of the base, and the height tells how many "copies" tall the solid is. For a cylinder, the base is a circle, so Volume = pi * r^2 * h. Their surface areas share a pattern too: two congruent bases plus a lateral (side) area that unrolls into a rectangle. A prism's surface area is 2*(base area) + (perimeter of the base)*height; a cylinder's is 2*pi*r^2 + 2*pi*r*h, since its unrolled lateral surface is a rectangle with width equal to the circle's circumference.
Pyramids and cones share a different pattern -- exactly ONE THIRD of the prism or cylinder pattern for volume: Volume = (1/3) * (area of the base) * height (demonstrable by pouring: it takes exactly three pyramid-fuls, or three cone-fuls, to fill the matching prism or cylinder with the same base and height). Their surface areas both use a slant height l (the distance from the apex down the SLANTED outer surface to the base edge, not the straight-up vertical height): a regular pyramid's surface area is (base area) + (1/2)*(perimeter of the base)*l, and a cone's is pi*r^2 + pi*r*l.
Mastery looks like: They correctly apply the volume and surface area formulas for prisms, cylinders, pyramids, and cones, correctly distinguishing vertical height from slant height where needed.
Common stumbles: Using the vertical height instead of the slant height in a pyramid or cone's surface area formula; forgetting the 1/3 factor for pyramid and cone volumes.